Menu
So this guy calls me last tuesday (or was it wednesday? doesnt matter) and he’s all worked up because his telehandler boom keeps dropping. Already changed the counterbalance valve, spent like $400 on it, boom still dropping. Now he wants to pull the cylinder and send it out for rebuild which is gonna be another $1800 PLUS the machine sitting there not making him money.
I’m like dude, before you do that…
Walked him through the basic test – cap off the pilot line, bleed the pressure, see what happens. Boom stops after maybe an inch of drop. BOOM (pun intended lol) – that’s your cylinder packings, not the valve. $240 fix vs $1800. You’re welcome.
This happens SO MUCH it’s not even funny anymore. Actually it is still kind of funny because people waste so much money assuming stuff instead of just testing properly.
Directional check valves. Pilot-operated check valves. Counterbalance valves. Load-holding valves. People call them different things but they all basically do the same job – control flow direction and hold loads in place.
The market for these things is apparently $500 million according to some research report I read (Archive Market Research if you care). Growing 7% per year. Construction equipment, excavators, aerial lifts – anything that needs to hold a load and not kill someone when the hydraulics lose pressure.
Parker makes the D-series directional valves, D1VW is probably their most common one. NFPA D03 mounting pattern (thats the 3/8″ size). HydraForce has like 2000 different cartridge valve models. Their EBLV Boom Lock Valve for mini excavators is actually pretty slick – combines the check function with proportional pressure control in one body instead of needing multiple valves.
Continental Hydraulics does manifold-mounted stuff, rated to 5000 PSI continuous which is honestly overkill for most applications but hey if you need it you need it.
Regular check valve = flow one way, blocked the other way. Simple.
Add a pilot port = now you can control when that reverse flow is allowed. Pilot pressure pushes against a poppet or spool, opens it up, boom you got bidirectional control.
Where this matters: excavator sitting on a hill, engine off. Without directional check valves trapping fluid in the boom cylinders, that boom is coming down. With properly working valves? Boom stays put. Operator climbs out safe. Nobody dies.
That’s literally the entire point of these valves – safety and load control.
OK so Parker specs say their D31VW needs 207 bar (3000 PSI) minimum pilot pressure. That’s at like room temperature with clean oil.
Winter in North Dakota? Hydraulic fluid gets thick. Real thick. That valve that opened fine at 250 PSI pilot in July now needs 350+ PSI in January. I had a customer, system would chatter in cold weather – open close open close open close – just hammering the valve seats. Operator is freezing his butt off AND the machine sounds like it’s gonna explode. Not great.
HydraForce’s G3 line is supposed to handle low temps better with redesigned geometry. Does it work? Yeah mostly. Better than old designs anyway.
70% of hydraulic failures = dirty oil. Not making that up.
Had a customer in Ohio (industrial press manufacturer). Using high-flow valves on progressive dies. Position drift started happening. Scrap rate went from under 1% to over 3% in like two months.
What happened? They switched to cheaper filters to save money. 25-micron instead of 10-micron. Those extra metal particles that got through? Big enough to lodge in the pilot poppet seats. Microscopic leak turns into measurable drift over an 8 hour shift.
We pulled the valves, every single one had metal contamination stuck in there. They spent probably $40k in scrapped parts trying to save $200 on filters. The math doesn’t math.
Fixed it by going back to proper filtration + adding offline kidney loop filter. Scrap rate back under 0.5%. Customer learned expensive lesson.
Load drifts down slowly = everyone assumes cylinder packings are shot.
Nine times out of ten? It’s the valve stuck open.
There’s this procedure (I learned it from heavy equipment forums which honestly have better info than half the manufacturer tech support):
If significant oil comes out the barrel end fitting when you try to move it = packings worn. If not = valve stuck open.
But people skip this and just replace the cylinder because “that must be it” then act all shocked when new cylinder drifts too.
Check the valve first! Takes 20 minutes vs 2 days for cylinder rebuild.
Got a call about a Cat 330C excavator pulling right when traveling. Both track relief pressures good at 300 bar. They tested the straight travel valve, tested the solenoid, even swapped hoses around. Problem stayed with the right track.
Ended up being counterbalance valve in the travel motor partially coming apart internally. Needed more pressure to operate that side. The straight travel valve was compensating by combining flow which is why it tracked straight when they ran an implement at same time.
But here’s the lesson – pilot line sizing and routing causes MORE problems than bad valves.
Too small pilot line (smaller than 1/4″ for valves up to 1″ port) = response lag. Opens slow, closes slow, system gets shock loads.
Too long pilot line (over 15′ with flex hose) = same problem.
Parker documentation says keep spool centerline horizontal. Can you mount vertical? Yeah. Will it last as long? No. Do people do it anyway because it’s convenient? YES. Then they call and complain valve failed early.
Parker D1VW: 345 bar (5000 PSI) max on P/A/B ports. Tank ports 103 bar (1500 PSI) standard.
That “maximum” rating assumes:
Run continuous at max pressure? You’ll cut service life 60-70%. The poppet seat surface wears down under repeated high-pressure cycles. Start seeing weeping around 8-10k hours.
Continental rates their D03 to 5000 PSI but their documentation (which is actually pretty good for once) recommends designing for 70-75% of max continuous if you want 15k+ hours without major work.
Does anyone actually follow this? Nope. Everyone designs to max rating, runs at max, then acts surprised when stuff breaks at 7000 hours.
Mobile hydraulics obviously – excavators, loaders, backhoes, ag equipment.
HydraForce excavator circuits usually need 4 check valves + 2 solenoid valves + relief valve for pilot control on those tiny 1-2.6 ton machines.
For wet/dirty construction sites – HydraForce E-series coils are IP69K rated. G-series has corrosion coating that actually works. I’ve seen valves from coastal install that looked like crap externally but still worked fine after 5+ years.
Material handling stuff – scissor lifts, boom lifts, personnel platforms. These use pilot-operated checks as SAFETY components which means you really don’t want to cheap out.
Trillium Flow makes pilot-operated pressure relief valves with tight shutoff at 98% set pressure. Matters when you’re dealing with hydraulic fluid in enclosed spaces with EPA watching.
The Lee Company makes TINY pilot-operated check valves – 250 Series is only 0.25″ diameter x 1.25″ length. Medical equipment uses these. Patient positioning tables, surgical robots. Totally different application than construction but same basic physics.
Industrial presses – directional checks for position holding between strokes. ARGO-HYTOS makes poppet valves with super low internal leakage. Critical when you’re holding position on 500 ton press and any leak = workpiece moves = scrap part.
People Don’t Follow Torque Specs
Parker D1VW mounting bolts: 16.3 Nm (12 ft-lbs).
What do people do? Grab an allen wrench, tighten til it feels tight. Then they get leaks and wonder why.
Over-torque = distorted manifold surface = leak paths Under-torque = movement under vibration = port damage = contamination gets in
It’s not that hard guys. Get a torque wrench.
Filtration On Pilot Circuits Gets Ignored
Main system maybe runs 10 micron filtration. But pilot circuits need 5 micron MINIMUM. Most manufacturer warranties REQUIRE this.
One 50 micron metal particle stuck in pilot poppet seat = no proper sealing = load drift = complete loss of directional control.
This is literally in every manual and people still don’t do it.
Electrical Connections
HydraForce E-series coils are IP69K rated which is great. But you STILL can’t submerge the valve body unless it’s specifically rated for underwater.
Moisture in electrical connections = intermittent operation that’s super frustrating to diagnose because symptoms come and go with temperature cycles. Machine works fine at 2pm, acts weird at 6am, works fine again at lunch. Drives everyone crazy.
Modern systems doing proportional control now but most directional checks are still binary – fully open or fully closed. Makes variable speed with load holding kind of a pain.
Parker D1FP and D3FW series do proportional directional control. 48 lpm (12.5 gpm) for NG6 size, 170 lpm (45 gpm) for NG10. Step response 100-165 milliseconds to reach 90% position.
Sounds awesome right? In practice electronic valve control has to work from -40°F to 160°F, constant vibration, occasional mud submersion. HydraForce PWM digital signal logic handles this better than old analog designs.
Real challenge though = environmental conditions in mobile equipment destroy electronics. I’ve seen systems where controller failures OUTNUMBER mechanical valve failures 3 to 1. You’re adding complexity to get better control but that complexity breaks in field conditions.
Trade offs man.
For load holding in mobile hydraulics, directional check valves still most reliable option. Technology is mature, we understand how they fail, integration straightforward with industry standard mounting (NFPA D03/CETOP 3 etc).
For safety critical stuff – personnel lifts, suspended loads, mobile equipment stabilizers – INVEST IN QUALITY. Price difference between OK valve and good valve is maybe $40-80. Price difference between it working right and dropping a load that hurts someone? Orders of magnitude higher.
Don’t cheap out on safety critical apps. Just don’t.
For flow control – make sure you actually NEED directional override. If standard check valve works, use that. Adding pilot control complexity without real benefit just makes more stuff that can break.
Parker – D1VW same day shipping on standard configs through distributor network. Custom spools 2-4 weeks. Pretty good.
HydraForce – maintains inventory on common cartridge models, similar lead times. Their tech support is actually decent too.
Continental – documentation is good, includes TÜV compliance certs and torque specs for everything.
Tech documentation varies a LOT by manufacturer. Parker gives you pressure drop curves, response times, mounting specs – all the good stuff. HydraForce website has CAD models and simulation tools you can download. Continental publishes compliance certificates.
For weird custom stuff or when troubleshooting gets hairy – call the manufacturer application engineers directly. Worth it. These guys have seen THOUSANDS of installations. They can spot problems that aren’t obvious from looking at datasheets.
Free samples usually available for evaluation (customs need deposits). CAD models in STEP/IGES formats standard nowadays. Cross sections for manifold design usually downloadable too.
Directional check valve market growing 7% per year because these things solve actual real problems. Load holding, drift prevention, anti-cavitation, safety interlocks.
Understanding how they work, what specs mean in FIELD conditions (not lab conditions), which manufacturers actually support their products – that’s what separates systems that work from systems that make you want to pull your hair out.
Also – and I cannot stress this enough:
READ THE INSTALLATION MANUAL FOLLOW TORQUE SPECS
USE PROPER FILTRATION DON’T MOUNT VALVES VERTICAL JUST BECAUSE IT’S CONVENIENT
And when someone says they got drifting cylinder, CHECK THE COUNTERBALANCE VALVE FIRST before rebuilding the cylinder.
Would probably save industry millions per year in unnecessary cylinder rebuilds if people just did this one thing.
OK rant over. Back to work.
Got valve problems? Questions? Drop comment below or call your local distributor. Most of us actually like talking about this stuff (yes really).
– Written by someone who’s been doing this too long and has OPINIONS about proper filtration
“A leader in hydraulic technology, A convenient choice around you”
