What is the most common cause of hydraulic valve failure?

Why do hydraulic valves fail?

Hydraulic valves are central control components in hydraulic systems, regulating flow, pressure, and direction. Failure can lead to unstable system pressure, uncontrolled operation, and even system shutdown. The main causes of hydraulic valve failure are diverse and include external environmental factors, internal wear, and improper operation. Experience shows that hydraulic valve failures often do not occur suddenly but are the result of long-term wear and tear.

Hydraulic systems operate in complex environments; high pressure, high circulation frequency, and the ingress of contaminants accelerate valve aging. Studies show that valve-related problems account for a significant proportion of hydraulic component failures, particularly in precision valves such as proportional and servo valves, which have extremely high cleanliness requirements.

Statistics and Analysis of the Most Common Failure Causes

According to several industry reports (e.g., Machinery Lubrication and Fluid Power World), 70–90% of hydraulic system failures are due to contamination in the hydraulic oil, with valve failures accounting for the largest share. Other factors include wear (approx. 10–15%), overheating (5–10%), and operator error (5%). Statistical analyses show that seizing and leaks caused by contamination are the most common causes, while fatigue wear predominantly occurs in high-cycle applications.

Types of Contaminants

Hydraulic oil contamination is the main cause of valve failures, accounting for approximately 80%. Contaminants are mainly classified into three categories: solid particles, moisture, and air:

Solid particles such as dust and metal shavings are the most common contaminants. They are generated during system assembly, through wear, or by external influences. Moisture enters through condensation or leaky seals and leads to emulsion formation in the oil. Air is present in the form of bubbles or dissolved substances and causes cavitation.

Mechanisms of Contaminant Effects on Valves

Solid particles scratch the valve spool like sandpaper, leading to seizing and internal leaks. Moisture reduces lubricity and accelerates corrosion; bursting air bubbles cause cavitation and damage the surfaces. The result is slower valve response and increased leakage.

Several studies (e.g., YorkPMH and Mobile Hydraulic Tips) confirm that contamination is responsible for 75–90% of failures. For example, particulate contamination causes 82% of the wear.

Other Common Causes of Failure

Although contamination in the hydraulic oil is the main cause of hydraulic valve failures (approximately 80%), the remaining 20% of failures are often due to other factors. While these factors individually account for only a small percentage, they frequently overlap with contamination, creating a complex and destructive effect that makes diagnosing and resolving problems more difficult.

Wear and Cyclic Fatigue

Hydraulic valves, particularly directional control valves and proportional valves, are subjected to high-frequency reciprocating movements during operation and can be actuated tens of thousands of times daily. Sustained cyclic loading leads to material fatigue, especially on the sealing surfaces of the valve cone and housing.

Typical Signs: The valve cone clearance gradually increases, leading to increased internal leakage and reduced system pressure resistance.

High-Frequency Applications: Injection molding machines, die-casting machines, and other equipment with high movement frequencies.

Accelerating Factors: Insufficient oil cleanliness exacerbates abrasive wear caused by particles, creating a vicious cycle.

Aging of Seals and Springs, and Wear of Valve Insert and Housing

Seal Aging: Rubber components such as O-rings and combination seals harden under the influence of high temperatures, high pressure, and the chemical effects of oil, becoming brittle and losing their elasticity. This frequently occurs in systems older than 2–3 years.

Spring fatigue: Constant pressure on the return springs of pressure relief valves, safety valves, and pilot valves can lead to permanent deformation or breakage, resulting in unreliable valve return or pressure drift.

Wear of valve insert and housing: Uneven wear on precision sealing surfaces (e.g., clearance of 0.005–0.01 mm) further increases the risk of leaks and blockages.

Underlying Causes of Seal Failures

Material aging and embrittlement: Long-term exposure to high temperatures (>80 °C) or ultraviolet radiation leads to the breakdown of rubber molecular chains.

Improper installation: During installation, the O-ring may be scratched, twisted, or insufficiently lubricated.

Incompatible oils: The use of mineral oil in a system with incompatible ester oils or additives can cause the O-ring to swell, soften, or shrink.

Improper Operation or Incorrect Settings

Excessive pressure: Setting the pressure relief valve above the nominal value leads to frequent opening of the valve cone and accelerates wear due to impacts.

Frequent sudden stopping and starting: Improper handling by construction machine operators generates high pressure peaks.

Malfunction of multi-way valves: Simultaneous actuation of multiple valves leads to system overload.

Overheating and Thermal Damage

Problems increase significantly when the temperature of the hydraulic system exceeds 70°C:

• Abnormal decrease in oil viscosity: The lubricating film thins, and direct metal-to-metal contact increases wear.
• Accelerated aging of all components: The lifespan of seals, springs, and coatings is shortened exponentially.
• Common causes of overheating: Clogged cooler, insufficient oil tank volume, high ambient temperature, and prolonged operation under full load.

Cavitation and Air Entrainment

Cavitation: When high-pressure oil is suddenly depressurized, dissolved air escapes and forms bubbles. These bubbles collapse in the high-pressure area, generating local temperatures of several thousand degrees Celsius and shock waves. These erode the surface of the valve core, forming honeycomb-like cavities.

Common locations: Near the throttling orifice of throttle valves and proportional valves; particularly pronounced with insufficient pump suction.

Corrosion and Environmental Effects

• Chemical corrosion: Corrosion occurs due to the decomposition of moisture, air, and acidic additives.
• Electrochemical corrosion: When different metals come into contact (e.g., steel valve body + copper sleeve), galvanic cells form in the electrolyte (water-containing oil).
• External influences: Systems in shipbuilding and the chemical industry are corroded by salt spray and acidic/alkaline gases.

These “other causes” may seem disparate, but they are often interconnected. For example, overheating accelerates the aging of seals, which in turn leads to leaks that further exacerbate the overheating, setting off a vicious cycle.

Typical Signs of a Hydraulic Valve Failure

A hydraulic valve failure rarely occurs suddenly; it is usually preceded by a series of warning signs:

Unstable system pressure or reduced flow rate

Slow pressure drop when holding pressure or weak actuator.

Common cause: increased internal leakage (wear of the valve spool, aging of the seal).

Stiff or sticking valve operation

The manual valve lever cannot be operated, the solenoid valve is not actuated, or remains permanently open.

Common cause: lodged particles or uneven wear of the valve spool.

Unusual noises

• High-frequency whistling: Typical cavitation noise.
• Knocking sound: Air ingress or pump cavitation.
• Humming sound: Problem with the solenoid coil of the proportional valve or vibration of the valve spool.

External oil leakage

Oil leakage at the sealing surfaces of the valve body, the solenoid valve push rod, and the pipe connections.

Outdated seals or an incorrect installation. Incorrect tightening torque is among the most common causes.

Warning signs (especially important to note)

• Unexplained oil temperature increase of 10–20 °C.
• Slowed system response and sluggish operation.
• Reduced control accuracy (e.g., deteriorated positional accuracy).

These signs often appear weeks to months before total failure, thus providing the best window of opportunity for intervention.

Detailed Cause Analysis of Hydraulic Valve Failures

Simply replacing the defective valve often only addresses the symptoms, not the root cause. Only by identifying the underlying cause can the problem be completely solved.

System problems behind contamination

• Insufficient cleaning of the pipelines after the installation of new machinery leaves welding slag and iron filings as long-term sources of contamination.
• Dead zones in the oil tank design prevent the drainage of accumulated dirt.
• Return oil directly impacts the oil surface, entraining large amounts of air.
• Accumulation of micro-damage on the valve cone: Small scratches initially do not impair function, but gradually lead to the accumulation of particles, creating a “snowball effect” that eventually leads to blockage.
• Improper use of differential pressure: The actual differential pressure (ΔP) was not considered during design. As a result, the throttle valve operates at high Reynolds numbers for extended periods, accelerating cavitation. In some systems, the differential pressure is artificially increased to achieve a fast response, which shortens the valve’s lifespan.

Hydraulic Valve Types and Failure Characteristics

Different types of hydraulic valves exhibit significantly different failure modes due to differences in structure and precision:

Directional Control Valves (e.g., Solenoid Valves)

• Most common problems: Sticking, leakage, solenoid burnout.
• High resistance to contamination, but susceptible to spring fatigue with frequent use.

Pressure Control Valves (e.g., Relief Valves, Pressure Reducing Valves)

• Typical failures: Pressure drift, high noise levels, failure to relieve pressure.
• Pilot-operated valves are more susceptible to clogging of the pilot oil circuit by particles.

Flow Control Valves (e.g., Throttle Valves, Flow Rate Control Valves)

• The throttle orifice is easily clogged by particles, leading to unstable flow.
• The compensation effect deteriorates with temperature changes.

Proportional Valves

• Extremely sensitive to contamination; particles can cause increased hysteresis, zero point drift, and reduced linearity.
• Overheating of the solenoid coil and failure of the feedback sensor are also common.

Servo Valves

• Highest precision, lowest clearance (3–5 µm), and highest demands on oil cleanliness (NAS 5 or higher recommended).
• Repair costs are extremely high in case of clogging or wear; replacement is usually the only option.

Systematic Diagnosis of Hydraulic Valve Failures

Systematic diagnosis is the core of troubleshooting hydraulic valves. Its goal is the step-by-step resolution of problems, from general to specific, from non-destructive to destructive methods, to avoid consequential damage caused by ill-considered disassembly.

Pre-inspection at the system level (pressure, noise, function)

• Work steps: Switch on the system and observe whether the actuators (e.g., cylinders, motors) move smoothly, in the correct position, and without creeping or shaking. Simultaneously, listen for unusual noises (e.g., whistling or knocking) near the pump and valve blocks and check the pipelines for vibrations.
• Tools: Pressure gauge (connect to the pump outlet and the valve inlet and outlet test points). Document whether the system pressure is stable and whether any fluctuations occur.
• Evaluation criteria: Pressure fluctuations of >5% or initially sluggish behavior indicate internal valve leaks or blockages.

Oil condition check (purity, moisture, gases)

• Work steps: With the system running, take an oil sample from the tank or a separate sampling port (avoid inaccessible locations). Check the oil color (normally transparent, light yellow oil; black/abnormal emulsion) and look for foaming. Send the sample to a laboratory for analysis or use a portable particle counter.
• Tools: Sampling bottles, vacuum pump, particle counter, moisture test strips.
• Evaluation criteria: If the ISO cleanliness level is above 16/14/11 or the moisture content is above 200 ppm, treatment is required.

Online Valve Function Test

• Procedure: Simultaneously measure the pressure difference between the valve inlet and outlet using a multimeter. Operate the valve and observe the flow/pressure response.
• Tools: Flow meter, pressure sensor.

Control Signal Test (Electro-hydraulic valve/Proportional valve)

• Procedure: Use a multimeter to measure the resistance of the electromagnetic coil (usually tens to hundreds of ohms). Use an oscilloscope to check if the input signal is complete and free of interference.
• Assessment: Coil burnout or signal distortion are common problems in proportional valves.

Valve Disassembly Inspection (Valve insert, valve body, seal, spring)

• Procedure: After stopping the machine and relieving the pressure, disassemble the valve. Clean the valve insert with diesel fuel or a special cleaning agent. Visually inspect or use a magnifying glass to check for scratches, wear (a gap greater than 0.01 mm requires replacement), seal cracks, and spring deformation. Measure the valve clearance with a feeler gauge.
• Note: Document the disassembly sequence to avoid mixing up parts.

Quick Assessment Method: “Listen, Feel, and See”

This experience-based method requires no instruments and is suitable for field service personnel to quickly locate 80% of common problems. Protective equipment must be worn and safety precautions followed while the equipment is in operation.

Listening: Identifying unusual noises

• Approach the pump station, valve block, and piping and listen quietly for 5–10 seconds.
• Common Noises and Their Meaning:
  • High-frequency whistling: Cavitation (throttle valve or proportional valve).
  • Intermittent knocking: Air ingress or air suction by the pump.
  • Deep humming: Vibration of the solenoid valve coil or the valve core, which is sticking and rubbing.

Tactile Inspection: Assessment based on temperature and vibration

• Carefully touch the valve housing, piping, and oil tank with the back of your hand (risk of burns!).
• Assessment:
  • Local heat generation (>70 °C): The valve has significant internal leakage or is sticking and generating heat through friction.
  • Significant vibration: Valve core blockage or unusual pump pulsation.
  • Follow the temperature gradient from the pump to the actuator to locate the heat source.

Three Observations: Observe the actuator, pressure, and oil condition

• Visually observe the cylinder extension and retraction movement, the pressure gauge needle, and the oil level/oil color in the tank.
• Assessment:
  • Actuator creeping/vibrating: Slow valve response or contamination.
  • Pressure gauge needle vibration: Air entrapment or pump malfunction.
  • Excessive foaming in the oil tank/dark oil color: Air ingress or heavy contamination.

With some practice, the problem can be narrowed down in 3–5 minutes. Combining this with a system diagnostic will yield more accurate results.

Maintenance and Preventive Measures for Hydraulic Valves

Preventive maintenance is crucial for the lifespan of the valve. Specific operating methods and recommended maintenance intervals are listed below:

Ensuring the purity of the hydraulic oil

• Filter new oil before filling with a high-precision oil filter with β10 ≥ 200.
• Regularly check the pressure difference of the main filter element during operation (replace the element if >0.3 MPa). Target: ISO 16/14/11 or NAS 7-8.
• Frequency: Monthly sampling and testing.

Regular maintenance and care (seals, springs, valve inserts)

• Major maintenance every 5,000–10,000 operating hours or 1–2 years. Disassemble and clean valves, replace all O-rings, reassemble seals, check spring length (replace if shortened by >5%), minor scratches on valve inserts can be polished and repaired.
• Tools: Torque wrench (assembly according to manufacturer’s specifications).

Operating temperature control

• Install an oil temperature sensor with an alarm function and an air/water-cooled cooler. Install additional cooling in summer. Ideal temperature: 40–60 °C, automatic shutdown if exceeding 70 °C.
• Frequency: Daily oil temperature check.

Good operating procedures and training

• Create standard operating procedures (SOPs) that prohibit sudden acceleration and simultaneous overloading. Operators should be trained annually.

Advanced oil management (pipeline oil, offline filtration)

• For continuous filtration during system operation, install a bypass offline filter cart (3–5 µm precision). Oil storage (sealed and protected from moisture) is the responsibility of the designated personnel.
• Frequency: Continuous operation or weekly circulation of 3–5 times the tank volume.

Valve Selection Considerations and Common Failures

• When selecting valves, consider flow rate (1.2 to 1.5 times safety margin), pressure, and contamination resistance. Avoid small valves with high flow rates (accelerated cavitation) or oversized valves (slow response). Prefer well-known brands with anti-contamination mechanisms (e.g., solenoid valves with filters).

Industry-Specific Maintenance Strategies for Hydraulic Valves

• Machine Tool Industry (High Precision): Monthly particle testing, target NAS level 5–6; proportional/servo valves annually; professional calibration.
• Injection Molding Machine Industry (High Frequency and High Temperature): Seal replacement mandatory every 2000 hours; enhanced cooler cleaning; oil temperature strictly < 65 °C.
• Construction Machinery (Shock Loading and Harsh Working Conditions): Improved coarse filtration + magnetic filtration; daily filter element inspection; operator training focusing on shock avoidance.

Partner with Industry Experts for Optimal Hydraulic Performance

Maintaining hydraulic valves is crucial for ensuring the efficiency, reliability, and lifespan of your industrial systems. At POZOOM, we specialize in providing comprehensive hydraulic solutions for B2B clients, including:

• High-precision valve maintenance and preventive servicing
• Custom hydraulic system audits and diagnostics
• Advanced filtration and contamination control solutions
• Training programs for operators and maintenance teams

With years of experience in servicing complex hydraulic systems across construction, injection molding, and machine tool industries, we ensure your operations stay smooth, reduce downtime, and extend equipment life. Contact us today to learn how we can optimize your hydraulic systems and protect your investment.

Get in touch with our experts and discover tailored solutions for your industrial needs.